Content Knowledge | LSTE 7317 | Creating, Using, Managing
The Advantages and Disadvantages of Mobile Technologies
Hello, World!
It seems clear that mobile technology is here for the long haul, and they have many benefits in the educational field. In this short paper I will cover three main topics that help to frame both the benefits and shortcomings of mobile devices in an education setting. The first will be to list 5 advantages that mobile devices have over traditional computers. Secondly, I will discuss 5 disadvantages of mobile devices over computers. Finally, I will present 5 arguments against the use of mobile devices in classrooms and why I have chosen to do so.
5 Advantages of mobile devices
The advantages of mobile devices are easily discovered, as we use these technologies every day for almost every digital need or desire. Mobile devices are just that, mobile. They can go just about anywhere and fit into a pocket, a bag, or just the palm of your hand. They have great portability (Harnish, 2022). This is an advantage over desktop computers because information is not limited to your location. Accessibility is wonderfully elevated with mobile devices. Secondly, communication is much easier and faster. It takes no time at all to pull out a cell phone, open the screen and send a message or email. Receiving communications is at the sound of a ding.
While desktop computers have excellent video capabilities, video and photos are taken with ease on mobile devices as they are more integrated into the device and often have higher quality imaging than their motionless counterparts. Desktop computers are highly customizable; however, they are not built to be user friendly in the way that mobile devices are. The keyword is easy. Mobile devices are easy to use. They are intuitive in a way that desktop computers are not. The final advantage I will mention is that mobile devices are more cost effective than computers (Harnish, 2022). That is not to say that they are cheap. Unfortunately, cell phones, smart watches, and tablets still run into the hundreds and maybe thousands of dollars, but they are still generally cheaper than most computers.
5 Disadvantages of mobile devices
Now to discuss the reasons why mobile devices are disadvantaged over desktop computers. In my own opinion, most of these issues are minimal and often overcome, with a few exceptions. Mobile devices are more likely to be a distraction as they are so easy to access. This subject will also be discussed in the next section. Standing in line, waiting for a bus, sitting at a red light, or even getting bored in a classroom (Cooper, 2023). Any number of reasons to pull out a mobile device and people have found it. Distracted driving due to cell phones caused more than 3,500 deaths in the U.S. in 2022 (Kwan, 2024). Desktop devices don’t have that problem.
Mobiles also have more security issues associated with them. Not only is it easier for them to be physically taken (Cooper, 2023), but they are more likely to be tracked using GPS or hacked (Kwan, 2024). While mobile devices are excellent in terms of creating, they are still not as powerful as desktop computers in areas of memory, processing speed, and graphic capabilities. They also have smaller interfaces making it harder to accomplish larger tasks such as word processing or building graphic media in which a mouse and keyboard would make the tasks much easier (Harnish, 2022).
Finally, navigation between multiple programs may take longer and be more challenging. Mobile devices can generally only run one program on the screen at a time. This is not always true, but the functions are limited. For example, someone can be on a video call and even though the screen may show their face to the caller, if they have a website pulled up and are scrolling, they will struggle to hold the phone steady, making communication more difficult. On a desktop, one can be in a business meeting on Zoom while simultaneously typing up a word document with the screen holding both programs next to each other for ease of engagement.
5 Arguments against mobile devices for classroom use
I think that there will be plenty of time in the coming weeks of this course where we will discuss the various benefits of utilizing mobile devices in the classroom for learning. For that reason, and for the sake of exploration and argument, I will discuss 5 ways in which mobile devices may cause challenges that could hinder learning. First are issues of accessibility but not for reasons one might think. While the mobile nature of these devices is advantageous, it could also be a distraction if used irresponsibly. Mobile devices have potential to be too accessible. Because our mobile devices, especially phones are so readily accessible, the temptation to pull them from our pockets and mindlessly scroll is high. It is an easily observable common practice for people to pull out their phone and scroll on their favorite app whenever there is a moment of dead space. When the aim for the classroom is learning, cell phones being present may prevent focus on important tasks at hand.
The second issue is that of the role of conversation in learning. In distance learning our technologies are necessary for communication with fellow learners. When in a classroom, the presence of mobile devices decreases the value of conversation by essentially saying that the value of the conversation only goes as far as the next disruption of a text message or phone call. In an interview conducted by Jill Suttie (2015), sociologist from MIT Sherry Turkle states, “Eighty-nine percent of Americans say that during their last social interaction, they took out a phone, and 82 percent said that it deteriorated the conversation they were in.”
An article on titled Advantages and disadvantages of mobile technology in education by Ahmad Ali (2023) discusses various advantages and disadvantages of mobile devices in the classroom, one of which suggests that screen time increases should be considered. With such frequent access to mobile devices at all times in our lives, there is a concern about overstimulation and overuse of screens when adding even more time within the classroom. Mental health concerns associated with overuse include issues with sleep, depression, and anxiety, issues that students often get enough of in their lives.
The fourth issue is straightforward. Connectivity issues can be a concern if mobile use is in an area of poor internet access or if applications do not function properly (Ali, 2023). This can take time to resolve and disrupt the flow of learning. Finally, issues of over-dependence on mobile technology in the classroom is a concern. This can be true of any kind of technology, however in the case of mLearning, the accessibility of devices can lead to issues related to critical thinking, internalization of information, and even cheating (Ali, 2023).
At the end of the day, it all has to do with balance and responsibility. The benefits of mobile devices in educational environments are many, but it is important to recognize the risks and challenges that accompany them. With proper awareness and preparation, mobile devices could potentially have limitless benefits in the classroom.
References
Ali, A. (2023, January 14). 10+ Advantages and Disadvantages of Mobile Technology in Education» Hubvela. Hubvela. https://hubvela.com/hub/technology/advantages-disadvantages/mobile-technology-education/
Cooper, M. (2023, June 1). Cons of Cell Phones in School. LoveToKnow. https://www.lovetoknow.com/parenting/kids/cons-cell-phones-school
Harnish, B. (2022, April 28). Mobile vs. Desktop: Which Is Better? Iloveseo.com. https://iloveseo.com/seo/mobile-vs-desktop-which-is-better/
Kwan, M. (2019, July 29). What Are the Disadvantages of Mobile Phones? LoveToKnow. https://www.lovetoknow.com/life/lifestyle/what-are-disadvantages-mobile-phones
Suttie, J. (2015, December 7). How Smartphones Are Killing Conversation. Greater Good; The Greater Good Science Center at the University of California, Berkeley. https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/how_smartphones_are_killing_conversation