Research | LSTE 7303 | Method, Ethics
eLearning Trend Resources
Hello, World!
As digital learning environments continually evolve, understanding the intersection of historical learning theories and modern technological advancement is essential for effective educational design. From the foundational principles of constructivism to the rapid emergence of artificial intelligence, virtual reality, and gamified learning platforms, the quest for relevance in modern education demands critical analysis. To explore how these shifts impact learner engagement, accessibility, and pedagogical efficacy, the following curated and expanded annotated bibliography examines key literature tracking the strategies and trends shaping the future of eLearning.
-

Virtual Reality in the Classroom: Transforming the Teaching of Electrical Circuits in the Digital Age
Virtual reality (VR) continues to be a rising trend in learning across the board. This study seeks to illustrate the continued enhancement and effectiveness of VR educational practices by conducting an experiment in an electrical circuits course. 27 students participated in the study and results showed an improvement in retention through virtual hands on experience with the material. Albarracin-Acero (2024) noted that “the integration of VR into classrooms has proven to promote equity by providing students from diverse backgrounds access to innovative learning tools.” That is particularly important when evaluating the effectiveness of the VR trend. A learning environment that allows for everyone to engage with the content will be a good candidate for long-term trending. As an eLearning strategy, I agree with the author’s assessment that unless VR can accommodate for challenges in integrated infrastructure, it will be a hard fight to popularize VR on a large scale.
-

Factors affecting Saudi medical students’ engagement during synchronous and asynchronous eLearning and their impacts on the students’ academic achievement: a national survey
This article contains research based out of Saudi Arabia medical school programs. It is a recent survey conducted using over 1,000 student participants. The survey primarily focused on identifying the effectiveness and preference of synchronous versus asynchronous learning strategies. Students appeared to prefer synchronous eLearning models, however, results indicated that performance improvement was higher through asynchronous models. In fact, while synchronous lessons were more highly preferred, it was reported that there was a lower percentage of interactivity meaning that a higher number of participants did not engage with the facilitator. This sits in contrast with asynchronous models where the ability to review material and engage with learning elements was higher. In terms of effective strategies, this study seems to infer that the accessibility of asynchronous eLearning can strongly improve learning retention over synchronous formats, particularly when the lectures are primarily based on an information acquisition view of learning.
-

The K-12 Online Evolution
This article discusses the relevance of online learning capabilities for K-12 education. The author promotes statistics relating to the increase of online and distance education programs in schools. Effective eLearning strategies are also discussed. For the purposes of my paper, the information in this article can be useful in supporting the effectiveness of collaborative eLearning trends. Considering the publication of this article was in 2009, it is interesting to find that synchronous collaboration trends in eLearning were already beginning to hold weight in online classrooms. There are interesting statistics regarding the use of eLearning in schools, however, the article is lacking in proper reference citations which minimizes the ability to verify statistical accuracy. Not to mention that the article is from 2009 and therefore the statistics are likely outdated. Regardless, the author makes a strong point when suggesting that “Those academic institutions with strong eLearning strategies will advance to help prepare students to reach their full potential in a digital age” (Arora, 2009).
-

Keynote: What is the State of E-Learning? Reflections on 30 Ways Learning is Changing
Curtis Bonk of Indiana University reflects on the state of eLearning in the world today and the trends that are most prevalent in what he calls the “age of education 3.0” (Bonk, 2016). He discusses three “mega trends” in modern education and the changes that accompany them. The trends of modern learning include learner engagement, pervasive access, and customization (2016). This piece is particularly helpful for my study, with a very succinct list of ways that eLearning is trending as a field. The way that technology is expanding the ability for engagement with content is a trend that will not soon be left behind. His discussion on the pervasive access to education digitally suggests that the ability to connect on a global scale will continue to improve learning, therefore continue to be in practice. Personal and modifiable learning online is a rising trend enticing more learning to take place in the digital space. More people are collaborating together to make learning what they want it to be, breaking away from traditional learning modalities .
-

History of eLearning: Evolution from Stenography to Modern LMS Platforms
This article travels through the history of learning trends dating back to the 1840s before eLearning, and through modern eLearning trends and platforms. The author suggests that “mobile learning, gamification, and social learning” (Bouchrika, 2024) are among the more modern trends because of their ability to leverage new technologies.
-

AI and ethics: Investigating the first policy responses of higher education institutions to the challenge of generative AI
The aim of this journal article is to highlight the ethical challenges inherent in the use of generative AI (artificial intelligence) such as ChatGPT in higher education settings. In approaching the subject, the article summarized existing ethical principle policies in institutions and then assessed how they can and are being translated to suit the issues generated by AI. The issues covered were accountability and responsibility, human agency and oversight, transparency and explainability, inclusiveness and diversity. Concluding remarks state that “The main ethical imperative is that students must complete university assignments based on the knowledge and skills they acquired during their university education unless their instructors determine otherwise” (Dabis and Csaki, 2024). In higher education, the greater concern with the use of generative AI appears to be a lack of quality detection tools that distinguish AI from student writing. This, of course, presents challenges in the learning space when trying to assess the learner’s retention of ideas and concepts. These pitfalls are important to note.
-

E-LEARNING TRENDS AND HYPES IN ACADEMIC TEACHING. METHODOLOGY AND FINDINGS OF A TREND STUDY
This research study intended to understand the growing eLearning technologies and methods of the time, specifically as they pertained to higher education. This is a German-based study and clarifies that the results are relevant to that region, though they do reflect the accessible technologies of the time elsewhere. The study presents a standout graphic representing what is known as the Gartner Innovation Hype Cycle, which shows the trajectory of an emerging technology by its maturity, adoption, and social application (Fischer, 2014). Results of their study show that learning management systems are among the most stable and utilized trends in eLearning, with social software among them. The study was conducted at a time when MOOCs were at its height and showed a significant popularity as an eLearning model, while the virtual setting was a hype trend not expected to become widespread in higher education. It would be interesting to see how that trend has changed in comparison to our current atmosphere (see Fonariuk, et al., 2023).
-

The Advantages & Disadvantages of Constructivism in the Classroom
This blog article by Dr. Patrick Gleeson provides a brief explanation of the Constructivist theory of education and its promotion of learning engagement. It describes both the positive outcomes of learning as well as common pitfalls of this approach. There is little in this post that will add to my study with the exception of one particular observation that I found to be poignant. “Unless the teacher remains disciplined in the use of such materials, the classroom experience can devolve into entertainment. Students exposed to this kind of teaching may be unprepared for the rigors, and occasional boredom, of the lecture-based teaching methods common in higher education” (Gleeson, 2011). This observation is addressing the in-person classroom experience, however, when applied to an online approach, it remains relevant.
-

Leveraging AI in E-Learning: Personalized Learning and Adaptive Assessment through Cognitive Neuropsychology—A Systematic Analysis
This informative research article explores the findings of 85 studies as they pertain to the effectiveness of AI (artificial intelligence) in eLearning environments. The focus is primarily on adaptive learning (AL), adaptive assessment (AA), and personalized learning (PL) using AI. There is particular focus on connectivist theory. “Connectivism, a digital-age-appropriate theory, states that learning is not limited to the brain of an individual but distributed within networks, and that the very ability of one to learn depends on their capacity to construct and surf networks” (Halkiopoulos, 2024). Topics of ethics also arise in the article emphasizing that AI uses historical data which can transfer bias in the development of PL as well as the sheer amount of data acquisition which brings to light issues of information privacy. These potential pitfalls are important to evaluate when AI is being considered as a tool in eLearning systems. Overall, the AI trend is only expanding its role in the eLearning space and this article concludes that it can be an ultimately beneficial option when used intentionally and monitored. This article is a great resource in the discussion for current eLearning trends.
-

The Impact of Metacognitive Instruction in Blended Learning on L2 Listeners’ Metacognitive Awareness and Comprehension
In this journal article, the researcher was attempting to determine the impact, if any, of blended learning strategies on what they call “L2 Listeners,” or learners of a second language. Their study called for learners to utilize both online sessions and offline tools to measure comprehension. They concluded that the use of blended learning environments where peer collaboration was involved suggested a significant effect on comprehension and metacognitive awareness (Lee, 2015). This study provides a good source of evidence supporting the use of blended learning as a strategy for improved learning. I will be able to utilize information from the study to support its benefits.
-

Historical Review of Learning Strategies Research: Strategies for the Whole Learner—A Tribute to Claire Ellen Weinstein and Early Researchers of This Topic
Much of this journal article is an in depth discussion of learning strategies as an area of research study. It addresses the trajectory of research trends in the field of behavioral and cognitive learning theories. This resource is informative in such a way as to provide insight into what theories of learning have gained popularity in the last century. This primarily being in the realm of metacognition and constructivism. McCombs (2017) begins with connecting the research efforts of the military in developing enhancing strategies for “student success in self-paced and/or computer-based military training environments.” She continues by recognizing the increasing popularity of constructivism. An interesting note, and one not often touched upon is the increasing understanding of socio-emotional learning in approaching education surrounding non-academic outcomes such as character development (McCombs, 2017) .
-

Expanded Reality: Just a Trend of our Time or do We Need Technology?
This article out of the Romanian Journal for Multidimensional Education examines the benefits and challenges of what it calls “expanded reality” in distance education. It explores the differences between virtual reality and augmented reality and how they are being used in eLearning. The article concludes that expanded reality in education provides many advantages in the field, and as technology continues to improve, the accessibility of such a trend will be more freely utilized. This resource will be particularly beneficial when I dig into popular modern trends in eLearning. There is a reasonable argument made for how expanded reality options in learning are gaining momentum. The article also lays out some of the disadvantages such as cost efficiency, accessibility, privacy, and even physical discomfort that provide insight into the pitfalls of the trend.
-

The Evolution of E-Learning Systems: A Brief History
This blog article provides a brief history of eLearning systems, from PLATO to modern LMSs and MOOCs. Some of the various features of these systems are discussed such as assessments, collaboration tools, gamification, and content delivery methods. The simplicity of this discussion will be helpful in developing a framework for my own exploration of popular eLearning trends. This source will also be helpful in highlighting the impact of the advancement of eLearning strategies on education. This is a description based discussion which provides little by way of scholarly references but it will be a good tool for describing the different tools used in the eLearning arsenal.
-

History & Context for Active Learning
This chapter discusses the history and relevance of constructivism and active learning as an educational strategy. Philosophies from such educators as Paulo Freire, John Dewey, Maria Montessori, Gilbert Ryle, Jean Piaget, and Lev Vygotsky are explored. While the primary aim of my study is strategies in eLearning specifically, it will be of great value to explore the historical context for learning strategies as a whole. This source will be a great exploration of one of the most regarded strategies of our time, constructivism.
-

Take A Trip Through The History Of E-Learning
This article provides a historical context for eLearning. It also includes a relatively comprehensive timeline of events that effect the evolution of eLearning strategies beginning with Pascal’s Calculator in 1642, extending to the Automatic Teacher in 1924, and continuing to the MOOC era of the 2010s. Overall, this article is simplistic in the extent of its information, which does not lend much to scholarly research. Where it benefits my study however, is in providing a look at the way trends evolved over time and how they adapted the technology that was available. It will be an easy reference tool for determining what trends to include in my study. Examples may include PLATO, CMI (computer-managed instruction), pioneered by Patrick Suppes of Stanford, which valued individualized instruction, OpenCourseWare through MIT, and MOOCs.