Application of Course Concepts in Science Instruction

When deciding how best to apply the principles learned throughout this course to a particular field relevant to my career goals, the clear and obvious choice for me was to select the topic of science and education. Below, I will discuss three main ideas explored in Chapter 15, Cognitive Approaches to Science: naïve science conceptions, expert-novice differences in science, and models for teaching science. Following the brief exploration of these ideas, I will map out how various concepts that we have studied throughout the course can influence and guide the discussion on how to best educate in scientific fields. Using these concepts, I will then apply them through 3 activities that will support the three ideas presented in the text. 

Ideas in science instruction

Idea 1: Naïve science conceptions

The idea presented here can be distilled down to say that we all experience the world around us in different ways. Our perceptions greatly influence how we think about the inner workings of the world. These are called naïve theories. Essentially, we try to make sense of scientific phenomena through the lens of our everyday experiences. These theories may sound well-articulated and believable due to a limited understanding of proven principles, which may appear correct even though they are not (Bruning, Schraw, and Norby, 2011). 

Idea 2: Expert-novice differences in science

One of the greatest issues that I run into as a laboratory trainer is that I have nearly a decade of expertise in the field, while the vast majority of technicians who enter my lab are doing so for the first time. The way that I approach problem-solving and understand concepts is much different due to my experience and previous knowledge. Bruning, et al. (2011) say that “Typically, experts will begin with fundamental science principles that often only are implied by problem statements. In general, they will engage in deeper and more complete problem representation than do novices and solve problems faster and better because of it” (pg. 343). Novice learners rely primarily on their limited experience where experts utilize all of their prior knowledge as well as experience. When educating in a scientific field, this is something to be aware of so that it can be approached accordingly. 

Idea 3: Teaching models in science

This idea centers on optimal strategies for teaching science to students. It calls for a focus on productive schemata building and the use of inquiry-based instruction stemming from constructivist theories of learning (Bruning, et al. 2011). Providing students with opportunities to be actively involved in the development of scientific literacy through inquiry is the foundation of this idea. Seraphin, Philippoff, Kaupp, and Vallin (2012) write, “Scientifically literate students understand that science is not only a body of facts, but also a dynamic knowledge-creation process involving scientific habits of mind such as critical analysis, curiosity, openness to new ideas, and inventiveness” (pg. 367). Students must be encouraged to ask questions, discuss concepts, and work on conceptual change to reduce their naïve conceptions and increase their expertise. 

Course concepts

The ideas listed above present issues that concern the education of science at all levels, from youth to adult professionals. I will now look at 4 course concepts explored throughout this course that can be used to address how these ideas are applied in the learning process. 

Concept 1: Metacognition

Metacognition essentially refers to how one thinks about thinking. Reflection and recognition of one’s thought process is helpful for discovering whether a particular approach to a problem or learning strategy is working. One of the reasons that experts in scientific fields show greater skill than novices is that they have well-developed metacognitive strategies that improve their depth of knowledge. This can take many forms such as self-reflection, note-taking, adjusting studying tactics based on the type of knowledge presented, planning, or self-evaluation. This type of metacognitive thinking is often well-practiced by experts while novices have not yet developed the skills through their experience in the field.  

Concept 2: Encoding and Retrieval

The learning of scientific theories is frequently produced through the encoding and retrieval of procedural and declarative knowledge. For young learners whose naïve theories permeate their understanding of scientific concepts, it is important to clear up misconceptions and incomplete schemata. The activation of prior knowledge is an important concept in encoding, which says that new learning always builds on it (Bruning, et al. 2011). When dealing with naïve beliefs, however, a common pitfall is their overreliance on the sufficiency of their prior knowledge. It is important to temper this with inquiry-based instruction as mentioned above.      

Concept 3: Problem-solving and critical thinking strategies

In trying to build schemata grounded in good scientific theory and less on naïve conceptions of science, it is important to utilize effective and appropriate problem-solving techniques. An example of a good strategy to solve problems associated with restructuring incorrect and naïve beliefs is means-end analysis. Guided discovery for scaffolding information can also be helpful by confronting errant beliefs. It allows learners to challenge prior knowledge through hands-on and inquiry-based instruction, which is fundamental to scientific learning.  

Concept 4: Reflective judgment

Perhaps a more integrated and specific metacognitive model for bridging the gap from novice to expert learner is the reflective judgment model of knowledge construction. Early stages of reflective judgment find the learner using personal observation and experience to apply knowledge. It is considered concrete and unchanging. As learners grow to later stages through instruction, they find more nuance, less blind certainty, and less objectivity. Of course, in science instruction, the point is to help learners challenge their unsound conceptions and discover more evidence-based understanding. Reflective judgment sees the result of conceptual change as learners deal with their conflicting beliefs.  

Learning activities

The activities below are intended to help learners engage not only with scientific concepts themselves but also how they approach learning scientific concepts. 

Activity 1: Putting naïve science conceptions to the test

This activity is intended to help learners in two ways. It requires them to confront their incorrect assumptions about a specific scientific phenomenon, and it helps them to recognize how easy it can be to let assumptions based on limited experience and knowledge dictate understanding. It will require the use of problem-solving techniques, reflective judgment, and metacognitive reflection. The teacher will ask the question, “Do bigger objects fall faster than smaller ones?” After discussion, the teacher will demonstrate dropping a common schoolyard ball and a flat sheet of paper at the same time. The common assumption is that the weight of the larger object (ball) is what causes it to fall faster. Demonstrate again with the paper crumpled tightly into a small ball. The paper should fall faster this time, indicating that it is not weight but air resistance that determines its fall rate. Through more discussion, not only have the learners begun to confront their assumptions, but they have also been given the opportunity to revise and restructure the way they fundamentally think about concepts. The actual exercise and demonstration can be interchangeable with other scientific concepts.

Activity 2: A problem-solving novice/expert dual

For this activity, learners will watch two short videos. One video will show a novice attempting to complete a scientific task, and the other will show an expert completing the same task. Between each video, learners will discuss the steps taken by each person to complete the task as well as their approach. The use of more strategic planning and problem-solving on the part of the expert can be highlighted here. In observing the more advanced strategies used by the expert, learners will be able to use metacognition to analyze their own thinking and approach.

Activity 3: Snap debates

This final activity will provide an opportunity for learners to present arguments for their understanding of concepts, reflect on challenges to those arguments, and on the other side, challenge others’ assumptions through inquiry. Learners will take turns preparing a short argument in favor of a relevant scientific principle. They will be given time to present, followed by a rebuttal by their peers. The learner in the “hot seat” will then be provided with an opportunity to respond. After each debate, further explanation by the teacher will help confirm or confront their arguments. This activity will support learners by requiring them to generate explanations for their hypotheses and revise their thinking based on new information. They will use problem-solving to construct arguments and metacognition to think about their reasoning throughout the debates. 

Conclusion

The ideas explored here show that effective science instruction is more than strictly presenting facts and theories. While that is a valuable aspect, arguably more important is creating opportunities for learners to wrestle with their perceptions, test their strategic thinking, and challenge their assumptions. With those tools, they will be able to gain stronger scientific literacy.  


References

Bruning, R. H., Schraw, G. J., & Norby, M. M. (2011). Cognitive psychology and instruction. Allyn & Bacon/Pearson.

Seraphin, K. D., Philippoff, J., Kaupp, L., & Vallin, L. M. (2012). Metacognition as means to increase the effectiveness of inquiry-based science education. Science Education International, 23(4), 366–382. 


Next
Next

eLearning Development